Firstly get yourself a coffee or a large dram of whisky ( the liquid type) you might need it …..
Barley / terroir and a comparison to the wine industry seems to be stirring within the whisky industry and with some it is a hot topic at the moment ! For those of you who have not noticed don’t worry all you are really missing is a circus performance and a lot of hot air, look to the skies and you might just see the balloons soaring high just behind the pigs flying high in the wonderfully blue skies above..
Lets forget the wine comparison at the moment because the whisky industry does not want to be the wine industry that’s why they make whisky and NOT wine..
Quote.. “When you buy a bottle of single malt Scotch whisky you are buying a bottle of barley “
Well when I buy a bottle of whisky I expect a bottle of whisky !! I want to drink it not chew on it.. And what about the production methods the water and the yeast or have the angels taken these too ?
( if you are confused the whisky is on the right !! )
Quote.. “Without barley, none of the flavours of single malt whisky are possible.”
In theory a true sentence but it is also ridiculous.. Why ? Well obviously if it is a malt whisky then it has to contain barley and that implies that the wood does nothing ! but wait a minute, whisky can also be made with wheat, corn, rye and oats! So if that is whisky then we can survive without 100% malted barley.
After all once a whisky is made from other grains and has spent its time within the cask ( let’s say 3 years and a day ) then there will be a lot of those notes that we associate with malt whisky so technically the quote is both right and ever so wrong !!
So let’s talk about barley..
There are two types of barley, winter barley and spring barley, modified down into strains that have been genetically modified / cross bred to produce better yields and stronger more versatile strains..
Spring barley is probably more noted for growing and use within Scotland and for the use within the malting industry, although winter barley can and is used to produce whisky.
Regarding winter barley, it is cheaper to grow Spring barley but it will often result in lower yields at harvest time therefore there is a greater call for spring barley to be grown for brewing/ malting purposes, However, it is easier to grow spring barley in Scotland due to climate and demands in the malting sector prefer the low nitrogen spring barley for distilling purposes.
Spring barley will suitably grow on a wider range of soils, ranging from clay to the lighter sand or loamy soils, but with that said spring barley is certainly more suited to growing on lighter souls with a Ph level between 6-7.5, the main importance to this statement is that the land is well drained..Barley is often described as a drought resistant crop with a requirement of 390 to 430 mm of rainfall for optimum yield, where a general water use requirement will occur for 21 to 28 days.
There are 3 main soil types which are sand, silt and clay but these can be divided down further into
What we also have to remember is how quickly a soil type within a single field never mind neighbouring field might change…
So we have our land sorted for this years crop ( don’t forget each year the crop is rotated, it’s not like a vineyard where the grapes are grown year upon year on the same land ) so what’s next.. Well Soil fertility will impact on which strain is chosen, there is plenty of evidence to show some varieties produce higher grain nitrogen which is not wanted for malting by the whisky industry…
Some strains such as Sienna or the widely used Concerto which is considered as a high yielding grain with high hot water starch extract and low grain nitrogen (this is the most important thing to the Distillers !! ) would be suited to a more fertile soil type as it will dilute the nitrogen level within the grain whereas something like Chariot ( no longer used ) would suit a less fertile soil types..
INSTITUTE OF BREWING AND DISTILLING APPROVED LIST
|Winter Varieties for Brewing Use||Spring Varieties for Brewing Use||Spring Varieties for Malt Distilling Use||Spring Varieties for Grain Distilling Use|
|Provisional Approval 2||
|Provisional Approval 1||
So we have our soil and strain so let’s plant it.. It will grow after all, won’t it ?
Unfortunately it’s not that easy, climate will effect how well the strain produces the starch fibres, yields and overall quality but so will weed control, disease and any nitrogen or chemicals that might be added to aid growth ( unless it is organic of course ) and the rate that it was actually planted with a recommended growth rate of 80-240 plants/square metre being the optimum for finer soils and up to 350 plants planted per meter squared for heavier soils due to poorer establishment results.. Barley can and will tolerate quite high plant populations without significant yield reductions but if the rate is below 80 plants per square meter the yield would most probably be reduced.
Phew we can relax now..
What about the depth we sow the seed ? The ideal depth for planting barley is around 50-75 mm down, if any deeper then the plant emergence may be reduced, also important is the depth of moisture within the soil, we need to plant seed into moisture at the minimum depth possible in order to obtain a successful establishment, the root must continue to grow into wet soil.
” Modern strains of barley have been genetically altered to have shorter roots”
You hear all sorts from people who don’t have a clue Or smoking something stronger than weed !!
Roots will find the moisture as long as it isn’t too deep and barley can extract moisture from as deep as 80cm ( Fact !! )
So we now need to add a little rain, add a little sunshine, check the moisture content ( it’s not just about thinking it’s ready you know ) and then bring in the machinery.
So we now have a trailer full of freshly cut barley ( hopefully around 12-13% moisture but not more than 15% ) Do we have enough sheds to store it field by field ( don’t be stupid ) nope it all goes together in a drying store assuming it is the same strain !! But this could be from fields miles and miles apart with several different soil makeup’s..
Then the moisture of grain in storage will affect its ability to maintain quality over time ( it does not last forever you know ! so don’t worry about the year it was cut as it will most probably be used within a year after all the farmer wants his sheds empty and the maltings will not have endless storage ) The lower the grain moisture the more stable its storage ability. However in practical terms it is more economical to store grain at around 12% moisture content.
So now Joe down the malting facility buys my corn, it’s shipped to him and of course it never gets mixed with any of wee Johnnies barley from up north, god forbid because how would we know what row it was harvested from never mind which field it came from and how much of Percy the pig or little Freddie the Friesians cows shit we spread on the field.. Its because the farmer kept it all separate after all..
Without all that info how on earth could jock at the distillery do his job correctly, the whisky would be crap and probably a little gritty.. Unless of course it was all propaganda !!
Ok I went a little off track there but come on, how much of the above do you really give a shit about ? My guess is none.. The master blenders, distillery managers are only worried about one thing and that is the high water starch extraction, it’s all about the starch and enzymes and the amount of alcohol they can get per ton of barley..
I could be very wrong here but I’m guessing those that decide to buy in the malted barley from the malters will have certain specifications to starch levels and protiens, and if advised to change strains in order to achieve the acquired results they would as they want to use as little malted barley as possible in order to achieve a high extraction of starch in order to achieve a high litres of alcohol to tonnage of barley used ratio..
What is starch ?
Starch or amylum is a polymeric carbohydrate consisting of a large number of glucose units joined by glycosidic bonds. This polysaccharide is produced by most green plants as energy storage.
Why is starch important ?
Starch is important because it is from the starch we get the fermentable sugars. Starch is made up of long chains of glucose molecules and have to be broken down into smaller molecules in order for the yeast to be able to turn them into alcohol.
Now with that said what is important..
The Distillers will be wanting something like 350-420 litres of alcohol per ton of barley used so if they get these results do you honestly believe they are worried about where the barley was grown the strain or the weather from that year ? Again you decide..
( I might be shot down with this figure )
Strains will come and go so on that premise they are not so important, weather will change so strains will be modified to contend with the climate, hmmm so does that make it less important ? You decide..
Again the only thing that important is what they can extract from the barley, not the strain or the terroir, so it looks like the ACTUAL BARLEY IS NOT GOING INTO THE BOTTLE AFTER ALL..
So what the hell is flavouring the finished whisky we drink ?
The barley will certainly give the whisky some flavour, it has to and that is very obvious but and I stress but it will mostly be at the new make stage and that cannot be disputed! But so will the yeast and both of these can be easily detected at the New make stage rather than the finished stage and that is a very important factor.. The distilling process will and does alter flavour profiles and eliminates most of what is gained from the areas the grain is grown in..
Now put the new make in the wood and something magical happens..
And believe it or not this is where it actually gets interesting !!
Get several samples from different casks where the whisky was produced with the same strain of barley and they will all be different ( bloody hell its magic ) does this mean the wood has done some work or did the fairies come in the night and add some magic mushrooms that made most of the industry think the wood will impart the majority of the flavour and colour.. No, the wood really does impart that flavour !!
Are you beginning to understand ?
Now take several samples of whisky from several casks that have all been distilled with different strains of barley, taste them and holy shit they are all different, it therefore has be down to the barley because of course you can determine exactly which flavours have come from the wood and which are down to the barley…….. Can’t you ? I think the answer you are looking for is NO..
We have to understand growing grapes and making wine is a totally different concept to growing barley and making whisky from that product, different strains will give you a difference and that I concede but it’s the stories, people and surroundings that are important but as a background and understanding behind the history of which ever distillery we want to concentrate upon..
I can understand it might be of interest to know what area it was grown, it might even make a difference in very small craft production where a true Terroir system could be put in but let’s not get shafted into thinking it makes any difference in anything produced on larger scale..
Is anyone still reading this ?
Go pour a bloody glass of whisky and do something worthwhile!!!!!!!
28 Comments Add yours
Thanks for any other informative article. I have noticed so many discussions on the topic and it is getting very confusing as to what importance there is for barley to glass for flavour and aroma.
I would like to thank you for the efforts you’ve put in writing this article. I’m hoping the same high-grade web site post from you in the upcoming as well. In fact your creative writing techniques have similar styles to myself. Really the blogging is spreading its wings quickly. Your write up is a great example of it.
A interesting read, thank you for the share.
It is very interesting to read the original post and comments posted by you and those who follow the site.
Barley as you know has had some research done concerning the production of beer but not really within distilling, the process is believed to have a far greater impact and therefore could in theory dispel the concept of terroir!
Thanks for the comment.. I think if you look st what Waterford are doing they seem to be very good at producing samples that have sat in casks for a small period of time that is just enough to impart flavour into the spirit.. Every cask will taste different and it is then very easy to show a difference and pass it off as the results of something else !! The only real way of doing this is at new make stage. It’s going to be very hard to prove it’s the barley and not the oak once it has spent time within the cask ! Each strain of barley will bring something different, we were first told Waterford will bottle field by field, it’s now farm by farm and might not even be fully like that.. Let’s wait and see what the future brings..
Hi. This is a very hot topic and I think the guys over at Waterford would strongly disagree with many of these points you raised. They are proving that each farm distillate tastes different which must prove that the barley is sufficiently important !
Whoa, that was a piece and a half! Very informative and plenty for me to think about, I am unsure which way I think about this topic but again I say this was very interesting.
This is a very subjective issue and there are arguments for both sides, I just believe the terroir that barley is grown is less important than some will have you believe..
Hi ocd whisky, A very interesting read indeed. I read in a few places about how the barley influence the flavour, it is interesting that you are saying differently but with a good argument.
Well that was pretty intense reading! I may not fully agree with the points but I understand the topic is far more complicated than the wine industry’s claim on terroir.
Still it was a good and informative read.
Thanks for reading and commenting, you are entitled to that opinion, I may not agree but isn’t that what’s it’s all about.. Pour a dram and enjoy 👍
Hope you had a sandwich and a large mug of the black stuff.. You know my thoughts lol 👍
I think the confusion is in the fact I am not of the opinion barley is the main thing, rather the opposite in fact.. My thoughts are that maturation and the production processes are far more influential.. Hope that helps.
There has certainly been a very interesting debate on social media
Bloody hell mate that was one hell of an epic read! Having spent time talking with you in the past I know how strongly you believe in the maturation process, great work 👍
So did you get down to the nitty gritty of all of this? I’d reckon after an article like that, that you’ve had a barn full of interest?
Do like your reasoning on this. Makes a lot of sense if you ask me.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jeez calm down mate! Grab a bottle of barley and have a crunch!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hello Sorren, Sorry but I have to disagree with you on this one, the barley is extremely important !
From what I have been told this is where we get the flavour and complexity from.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Having read your article, I tend to say that I agree with what you’ve written and explained.
I’ve seen the discussion on social media too, and hasn’t it been friendly…nope, it’s been quite volatile and unfriendly!! I completely understand what you have explained regarding the make up of the barley, and what it is that a distiller would be looking for in order to achieve the new make spirit (not water..) that fits the flavour profile of whatever distillery is producing.
Surely it IS down to the grade of the barley?
Your explanation of the soil types and ph values and how they can change and be different in several areas within even an acre (let’s say, and also that seems completely obvious) isn’t it then down to using the seed/strain of whatever grows best in that location. Surely a farmer who knows what grain grows best (and what he can sell) will be at the forefront of what he grows? And from there, one would imagine tests of that grain would dictate what it would be best used for?
Someone naively made a comment in response to that of a fellow on social media yesterday, they asked about the effects of wood on the flavour of the whisky? To say they were shot down in flames would be putting it mildly… oddly one would have thought that the cask marrying with the new make would have been a huge part of the process. If not why don’t they use something else? Plastic tanks anyone?? (And yes I’m being sarcastic on that.)
I read some information that I was sent yesterday, that appeared to be directed towards brewing beer. Yet this is about whisky.
I heard a discussion on this point very recently. You could have four casks all distilled on a certain date and after x amount of years 2 could be sensational and the others for whatever reason just don’t hit the mark… is that down to the spirit or the wood? I say the wood. But I would.
However, good read. Keep it up!! Very informative!
Now duck, there’s a flying pig overhead!!
I am a little confused Sorren, why would you think that the barley is the be all and end all of whisky flavour ? It is surely down to the production process and maturation period.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I can see the point to the argument but would it also depend on the size of the distillery? I would agree that at the new make stage certain things are more noticeable than at final product stage and therefore it shows the cask has a greater influence on the “ finished article”
I also think that this topic will really split the thoughts of the reader!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Very interesting concept, magic mushrooms and fairies makes me question ones sanity
LikeLiked by 1 person
LikeLiked by 1 person
I read it.
LikeLiked by 1 person